The Enchanting Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar in Islamorada
Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Islamorada is renowned as the "Sportfishing Capital of the World," a string of islands where turquoise waters meet endless horizons.
Amid this tropical paradise stands the Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, often affectionately called the Lorelei Resort by locals and visitors alike for its resort-like ambiance of relaxation and waterfront indulgence.
Located at Mile Marker 82 on the bayside, this iconic establishment has been a beacon for travelers since its inception, drawing crowds with its breathtaking sunsets, fresh seafood, and laid-back vibe.
More than just a dining spot, the Lorelei embodies the spirit of the Keys—casual, vibrant, and eternally enchanting, much like the mythical siren from which it draws its name.
The history of the Lorelei traces back to 1952, when it first opened its doors as a simple roadside eatery in the Upper Keys.
Over the decades, it has evolved into a beloved landmark, earning the moniker "The Pulse of Islamorada" for its role as a social hub where locals and tourists converge.
In 1986, a significant chapter began when former owners Frank Kulisky and Richard Jacob, along with partners, took over the property.
They revitalized the venue, enhancing its appeal while preserving its authentic Keys charm. One of the most striking features is the giant blonde mermaid sign that greets visitors from the Overseas Highway—a whimsical, roadside attraction-style icon that has become synonymous with the Lorelei.
Recently, in 2024, this mermaid received a fresh makeover by a local artist, restoring her siren allure and ensuring she continues to lure passersby.
The sign's restoration was celebrated as a return to "siren status," symbolizing the enduring magic of the place.The name "Lorelei" itself is steeped in lore, drawing from German folklore.
In legend, the Lorelei is a beautiful siren perched on a rock along the Rhine River, whose enchanting song lures sailors to their doom.
This mythical tale of seduction and beauty perfectly mirrors the Lorelei in Islamorada, where the stunning bayside views and melodic live music "enchant" guests, creating unforgettable moments as the sun dips below the horizon.
The giant mermaid sign reinforces this connection, serving as a playful nod to the siren's call. It's no wonder the venue is often described as enchanting couples and families alike, blending romance with the raw beauty of Florida Bay.
Today, the Lorelei offers a full spectrum of amenities that make it feel like a mini-resort. Open daily from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., it caters to all meals with a menu emphasizing fresh, local seafood.
Breakfast features classics like eggs Benedict and tropical fruit platters, while lunch and dinner highlight dishes such as conch fritters, mahi-mahi tacos, and lobster tails—many sourced from the surrounding waters.
Guests can even bring their own catch for the kitchen to prepare, adding a personal touch to the dining experience.
The Cabana Bar serves up signature cocktails like the Lorelei Sunset Punch, made with rum, pineapple, and a splash of grenadine, perfectly timed for the daily happy hour from 4 to 6 p.m.
For families, there's a kid's menu with simple favorites, ensuring everyone feels welcome. The venue accommodates large groups and is pet-friendly in outdoor areas, with options for beachside seating or shaded cabanas overlooking the marina.
What truly sets the Lorelei apart is its vibrant events and entertainment lineup. Live music plays seven nights a week, featuring local talents like singer-songwriter Micah Gardner, who performs acoustic sets blending reggae, rock, and island tunes.
The Sunset Celebration is the star attraction, voted the best sunset spot year after year. As the sky transforms into hues of orange and pink, guests sip drinks, sway to the music, and soak in the views—often arriving by boat to dock at the marina for an authentic Keys experience.
The Lorelei also hosts weddings and special events, with its waterfront backdrop providing a picturesque setting for ceremonies and receptions.
Nearby activities abound: Islamorada's world-class fishing charters depart from adjacent docks, and snorkeling or kayaking in the bay is just steps away.
Visitor reviews paint a picture of pure bliss. Travel + Leisure calls it a "perfect place for a sunset meal," praising the casual arrival options and lively atmosphere.
Conde Nast Traveler highlights the "stunning sunsets with a side of fresh seafood," while the Star Tribune urges visitors to "drink in the island life" for its value and vibe. Yelp users rave about the generous portions and unbeatable views, with one noting it's a "must-stop on any Keys road trip."
Even Tripadvisor reviewers appreciate its tavern-like feel and affordable American fare.
In a world of fast-paced travel, the Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar offers a timeless escape—a place where the lore of the sea meets the warmth of Keys hospitality.
Whether you're chasing sunsets, savoring seafood, or simply unwinding with live tunes, this Islamorada gem promises to captivate. As the mermaid sign beckons from the highway, heed her call; you won't regret it.
Nautical Mile Magazine
